
On 19 November the world got a split screen. In Shenzhen, Xi Jinping hosted Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin for what he called a "groundbreaking" trilateral, at which the three agreed to talk about reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation. In Berlin, roughly three dozen governments met as the Coalition of the Willing, the group that has backed Kyiv since early 2025, with Volodymyr Zelensky, NATO's Mark Rutte and Ursula von der Leyen in the room.
Friedrich Merz made the contrast explicit. "A Yalta format will not bring peace," the German chancellor said, a pointed reference to the 1945 conference where great powers carved up Europe without asking most Europeans. He said he expects new Ukraine peace talks to happen soon, with Europe sitting alongside the United States, Russia and Ukraine.
Crucially, Washington did not boycott Berlin. Trump's envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner attended and briefed Merz on the China talks, and Trump reportedly joined briefly by video. "President Trump wants to make a deal with Europe by his side. He's not looking to impose anything unilaterally," Kushner said. Trump himself told NBC News he agreed with Zelensky that the US should not make decisions on Ukraine behind Kyiv's back, while rating Shenzhen "12 out of 10."
Then came Putin's move. The Kremlin invited European leaders to Moscow through diplomatic channels to discuss ending the war, arguing that European security without Europe makes no sense. But he made no commitment that Europeans would get a formal role in any peace process. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov declined to say who exactly had been invited, and said Europe's negotiators had not yet contacted Moscow. A European diplomatic source told Russian state agency TASS that a trip to Moscow was not discussed in Berlin.
Europe does at least know who would speak for it. After EU leaders met informally in Dublin on 13 November, António Costa said the bloc's delegation would combine Commission and Council officials with Germany, France, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom: seven representatives in all.
Behind the geopolitics sat money and hardware. The agenda covered the Commission's proposed €45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027, the NATO-run PURL scheme that buys US air defence for Kyiv, a winter package against ballistic missiles, and legally binding security guarantees that could include a multinational force. Germany and Norway each pledged $300 million to PURL. Poland said it would add nothing for now. Bulgaria floated humanitarian aid rather than weapons it cannot afford.
The coalition also showed its cracks. Slovakia's Robert Fico said his country "wasn't, isn't and won't be" part of it. In Warsaw, officials made no secret of their nerves ahead of the Shenzhen meeting, given how unpredictable Trump's dealings with Putin have been.
Europe has spent months begging for a seat at the Ukraine table. It now has an invitation, a negotiating team and a US administration saying the right things. That is real progress. But Putin's offer is designed to split as much as include: a trip to Moscow with no guaranteed role risks legitimising the Kremlin's terms while giving Europe little say over them. The test for Merz and his partners is whether they can turn Berlin's show of unity into leverage before the Shenzhen club writes the outline without them. EU leaders meet next week to settle the €45 billion loan, and that decision will say more about Europe's weight than any invitation.
